This article is available to subscribers. Subscribe now. Already have an account? Sign in

Original ArticleFree PreviewArchive

Prolongation of the Disease-Free Interval in Surgically Treated Rectal Carcinoma

List of authors.
  • Gastrointestinal Tumor Study Group

Abstract

To assess the effects of postoperative radiation therapy and chemotherapy on tumor recurrence and patient survival, 227 patients (data on 202 of whom were analyzed) who had undergone "curative" surgical resection for rectal adenocarcinoma were prospectively and randomly assigned to one of four treatments: no adjuvant therapy (concurrent controls, 58 patients), postoperative radiotherapy with 4000 or 4800 rad (50 patients), postoperative chemotherapy (fluorouracil and semustine [methyl-CCNU], 48 patients), or a combination of radiation therapy and chemotherapy (46 patients). Five years after the entry of the last patient and with a median follow-up of all survivors for 80 months, the recurrence rate was highest among the control patients (55 per cent) and lowest among the patients receiving a combination of adjuvant radiation and chemotherapy (33 per cent). Time to tumor recurrence differed significantly among the four treatment groups (P<0.04); it was significantly prolonged by combined radiation and chemotherapy as compared with resection alone (P<0.009). Overall survival did not differ significantly among the treatment groups. The superiority of the combined-modality regimen appeared to be attributable to the effects of radiation therapy and chemotherapy in controlling local and distant recurrences, respectively. We conclude that this study provides evidence supporting the use of postoperative radiation therapy in conjunction with chemotherapy in patients who have had "curative" resection of rectal cancer with involvement of perirectal fat or regional nodes or both (Stages B2 and C). (N Engl J Med 1985; 312:1465–72.)

Funding and Disclosures

Address reprint requests to GITSG Operations Office/The Emmes Corporation, Suite 214, 11325 Seven Locks Rd., Potomac, MD 20854.

Supported in part under contracts (1-CM-57032–57035, 53844, 67093–67097, 87193, and 17371) with the U.S. Public Health Service.

We are indebted to Drs. Robert Shalek and William Hanson and the Radiological Physics Center (Houston), and to Jane Barrett, R.N. (GITSG Statistical Center, EMMES Corp., Potomac, Md.).

Author Affiliations

From the institutions and contributors of the Gastrointestinal Tumor Study Group (* denotes member of Writing Committee, and † study chairman): Roswell Park Memorial Institute (Buffalo, N.Y.) — E. Douglas Holyoke, M.D.,* Arnold Mittelman, M.D.,† Alvin Panahon, M.D., and John Pickren, M.D.; EMMES Corporation (Potomac, Md.) — Donald M. Stablein, Ph.D.,* Joel W. Novak, M.S.,* Susan S. Ellenberg, Ph.D., Anne S. Lindblad, M.S., and Patrick R.M. Thomas, M.B.* (Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, St. Louis); Mayo Clinic (Rochester, Minn.) — Charles G. Moertel, M.D.,* Louis H. Weiland, M.D.,† Michael J. O'Connell, M.D., Allan J. Schutt, M.D., Joseph R. Rubin, M.D., Donald C. McIlrath, M.D., and Donald S. Childs, M.D.; Albany Medical College (Albany, N.Y.) — John Horton, M.B., Ch.B., Charles Eckert, M.D., and John Ruckdeschel, M.D.; Milan Italy — Gianni Bonadonna, M.D., Leandro Gennari, M.D., Angela Moliterni, M.D., and Angelo Lattuada, M.D.; University of Miami (Miami) — Howard E. Lessner, M.D., Jamie Barkin, M.D., Martin H. Kalser, M.D., Alan Livingstone, M.D., and Richard S. Kaplan, M.D.; Dana–Farber Cancer Institute (Boston) — Robert J. Mayer, M.D., Jacob J. Lokich, M.D., Arnold W. Malcolm, M.D., Richard E. Wilson, M.D., and Glenn D. Steele, Jr., M.D., Ph.D.; Memorial Sloan–Kettering Institute (New York)—Robert B. Golbey, M.D., and Maus Stearns, Jr., M.D.; Georgetown University Medical Center (Washington, D.C.) — Philip S. Schein, M.D., Frederick P. Smith, M.D., and Paul Woolley, M.D.; Yale University (New Haven, Conn.)—Elliot M. Livstone, M.D.,* Arthur H. Knowlton, M.D.,† Hastings K. Wright, M.D., John Marsh, M.D., and Joseph Weissberg, M.D.; University of California, Los Angeles (Los Angeles) — Kenneth P. Ramming, M.D.; University of Chicago (Chicago) — Bernard Levin, M.D., Warren Enker, M.D., Jeannie J. Kinzie, M.D., and Robert Riddell, M.D.; Mount Sinai Medical Center (New York) — Howard W. Bruckner, M.D.,* Arthur A. Aufses, M.D., and Jose Barba, M.D.; and University of Southern California (Los Angeles) — Malcolm Mitchell, M.D., and Joseph Bateman, M.D.

Print Subscriber? Activate your online access.