Perspective
Immigrants and Health Care — At the Intersection of Two Broken Systems
N Engl J Med 2007; 357:525-529August 9, 2007
- Article
At a primary care clinic in Montgomery County, Maryland, where I volunteer, the patients are uninsured immigrants from Latin America or West Africa. Many are day laborers, house cleaners, or construction workers; most do not speak English. Several months ago, I saw a middle-aged Hispanic baker with profound weakness, fatigue, limb swelling, and severe muscle pain, who had to be hospitalized for myxedema. Fortunately, a local charity agreed to pay most of her hospital costs, and she's now receiving thyroid hormone–replacement therapy — but with regular care, her hypothyroidism could have been diagnosed earlier and hospitalization averted. Another day, I tried to persuade a reticent West African man who had been tortured in prison that psychological counseling might help his chronic pain. However, mental health services for uninsured immigrants are sparse, and the man was reluctant to venture to a distant part of Washington, D.C., to a program for torture survivors. A third patient, a man in his 40s, came in with a nearly empty bottle of eyedrops, which he had brought from Ghana to take for glaucoma. The disease had already blinded him in one eye, and the vision in his other eye had been fluctuating. He needed a complete eye exam and visual-field testing, but arranging timely referrals to specialists is often difficult for caregivers treating the uninsured. I wrote him a prescription, and we managed to set up an appointment at a hospital-based ophthalmology clinic that accepts a limited number of uninsured patients.
For recent immigrants — especially the estimated 12 million who are here illegally — seeking health care often involves daunting encounters with a fragmented, bewildering, and hostile system. The reason most immigrants come here is to work and earn money; on average, they are younger and healthier than native-born Americans, and they tend to avoid going to the doctor. Many work for employers who don't offer health insurance, and they can't afford insurance premiums or medical care. They face language and cultural barriers, and many illegal immigrants fear that visiting a hospital or clinic may draw the attention of immigration officials. Although anti-immigrant sentiment is fueled by the belief that immigrants can obtain federal benefits, 1996 welfare-reform legislation greatly restricted immigrants' access to programs such as Medicaid, shifting most health care responsibility to state and local governments. The law requires that immigrants wait 5 years after obtaining lawful permanent residency (a “green card”) to apply for federal benefits. In response, some states and localities — for instance, Illinois, New York, the District of Columbia, and certain California counties — have used their own funds to expand health insurance coverage even for undocumented immigrant children and pregnant women with low incomes. Other states, however, such as Arizona, Colorado, Georgia, and Virginia, have passed laws making it even more difficult for noncitizens to gain access to health services.
Whether or not they have health insurance, immigrants overall have much lower per capita health care expenditures than native-born Americans,1 and recent analyses indicate that they contribute more to the economy in taxes than they receive in public benefits. In a study from the RAND Corporation, researchers estimated that undocumented adult immigrants, who make up about 3.2% of the population, account for only about 1.5% of U.S. medical costs.2 Many immigrants do not seek medical treatment unless they are injured or acutely ill; at our clinic, patients with type 2 diabetes often have florid symptoms and even incipient renal damage by the time their disease is diagnosed.
One study found that annual per capita expenses for health care were 86% lower for uninsured immigrant children than for uninsured U.S.-born children — but emergency department expenditures were more than three times as high.1 Although U.S. hospitals must provide emergency care without first asking about income, insurance, or citizenship, early diagnosis and treatment in a primary care setting are both medically preferable and a better use of resources. “If people keep postponing medical care because they're so concerned about being sent back over the border,” noted Elizabeth Benson Forer, executive director of the Venice Family Clinic, a venerable free clinic in Los Angeles that serves many immigrants, “then you can end up with some pretty horrendous health situations.”
Immigrants live, work, and attend school in communities throughout the country; laws and bureaucratic barriers that reduce their use of key preventive health services, such as immunizations and screenings for infectious disease, make for bad public health policy, and denying immigrants primary care ultimately increases health care costs for everyone. For example, labor and delivery costs for undocumented immigrant women are covered under the federal and state emergency Medicaid program, but most states do not cover prenatal care, and there is no coverage for family planning. Some of my patients say they would like to use oral contraceptives or an intrauterine device or undergo a tubal ligation, but they can't afford it. And immigrants, like native-born Americans, are vulnerable to chronic diseases; as my colleague, nurse practitioner Lois Wessel, notes, “Even the 25-year-old day laborers are eventually going to become 45-year-olds, probably still undocumented, with hypertension and diabetes. . . . Life in America is going to make them become not so healthy.”
Recently, a bipartisan group of U.S. senators, with White House support, introduced an immigration bill that offered the best chance in years of achieving substantial reform of a dysfunctional system. However, the bill met with opposition from both conservatives and liberals and was killed in the Senate this past June, quashing all hope of immigration reform during the current administration. State legislatures this year are considering a record number of anti-immigrant measures, and the Senate bill's demise heightens their chances of passage. “You will see the states and cities scrambling to pass their own laws and regulations, and you're going to get a completely contradictory set of policies,” Senator John McCain (R-AZ) predicted in a Washington Post article on July 8. In many areas of the country, one consequence is likely to be reduced access to health care for immigrants.
Noncitizens make up about 20% of the 46 million uninsured people in the United States. Hospitals generally do not collect information on patient immigration status, and there are no reliable national figures on hospital costs for undocumented immigrants. Nevertheless, the soaring cost of uncompensated care (see graph A
Cost of Uncompensated Care (Panel A), Number of Unauthorized Immigrants (Panel B), and Number of Uninsured People (Panel C) in the United States.) has made the problem of providing care for uninsured immigrants a hot political issue, particularly in border states and those (such as the southeastern states) whose immigrant populations have grown rapidly in recent years. Some uninsured immigrants needing emergency treatment (including pregnant women, children, adults with dependent children, and elderly, blind, or disabled patients with incomes below Medicaid thresholds) qualify for emergency Medicaid coverage. In many other cases, hospitals receive no payment for their care, although in 2003 Congress appropriated $250 million per year for 4 years (starting in 2005) to partially compensate hospitals for treating undocumented immigrants.A recent study found that although emergency Medicaid spending for immigrants in North Carolina grew by 28% between 2001 and 2004, it still represented less than 1% of the state's Medicaid budget.3 More than 80% of that spending was for childbirth and complications of pregnancy, and major injuries accounted for nearly one third of the rest. In California, emergency Medicaid spending for uninsured immigrants for fiscal year 2007 exceeded $941 million, according to Kim Belshé, secretary of the California Health and Human Services Agency. “Clearly, there are medical needs faced by this population,” said Belshé, “and the emergency room is not the most cost-effective place for [addressing] them.” In addition, undocumented immigrants may account for as much as $750 million annually of the cost of uncompensated care in California hospitals — about 10% of the annual total — since they represent about 10% of the state's emergency department patients, according to Jan Emerson, vice president of external affairs for the California Hospital Association. “Almost half of the hospitals in California are currently operating in the red,” she said. “It would not be fair to place the blame solely on undocumented immigrants, but certainly, they are a contributing factor.”
The chief sources of outpatient care for uninsured immigrants are public clinics and community health centers. Such clinics are often sparse in suburban and rural areas that have recently faced an influx of immigrants. Even in cities with strong community-clinic networks and a long history of serving immigrants, access to care is uneven. For example, at the Venice Family Clinic, a bilingual nurse educator runs health and exercise classes in Spanish and English for patients with diabetes, pregnant women receive free state-subsidized prenatal care, and there are regularly scheduled clinic sessions for victims of torture and human trafficking. Yet arranging specialty referrals is a constant challenge — it usually entails sending patients to outpatient clinics at county hospitals, where some have to wait as long as a year for an appointment. In the Washington, D.C., area uninsured women, including undocumented immigrants, can get free annual mammograms and Pap smears through subsidized cancer-screening programs, but follow-up treatment for abnormal findings other than cancer is usually not included, and many clients have no source of primary care, as noted by nurse practitioner Wessel, who works monthly at one such program. “Patients come in year after year” for Pap smears — “but they've never had their blood pressure checked,” she said. “We don't check it, because all we're financed to do is cervical- and breast-cancer screening.”
In states seeking to expand insurance coverage, the question of including undocumented immigrants is a thorny one. About 1 million of California's 4.8 million uninsured residents are undocumented adults, and about 136,000 are undocumented children.4 As part of a proposal for comprehensive health care reform, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger is seeking to provide health insurance coverage (through Medicaid and the State Children's Health Insurance Program, or SCHIP) to all children with family incomes at or below 300% of the federal poverty level, regardless of immigration status. Although there is considerable public support for insuring undocumented immigrant children, Republican state legislators “do not believe that state general fund revenues should be invested in people who are here illegally,” said health secretary Belshé — “and that extends to children.”
The federal Medicaid program has always been restricted to U.S. citizens and legal residents, but recent federal and state laws designed to strengthen enforcement of eligibility rules have created new barriers, even for infants and children who are citizens, and have had a chilling effect on other programs providing health services for immigrants. The 2005 Deficit Reduction Act requires all persons applying for or renewing Medicaid coverage to provide proof of identity and U.S. citizenship. Since that law went into effect, at least eight states have reported dramatic declines in Medicaid enrollment, and some Medicaid-eligible infants and children have gone without immunizations and needed medical care because of delays in coverage.5
In Georgia, which last year passed a law requiring immigrants to show proof of legal residency in many situations, “we've started seeing a lot of kids not going to the doctor,” said Flavia Mercado, a pediatrician who runs the International Medical Center at Atlanta's Grady Memorial Hospital. “A lot of my clients are leaving and going to other states, and a couple are even going back to their country. Everyone is very fearful.” She said that Atlanta organizations are scaling back health services for Hispanics and have stopped sponsoring Hispanic health fairs, fearing that they will be raided by police or immigration officials. Meanwhile, faced with rising health care costs and increasing numbers of uninsured persons, the state's Medicaid program has sharply reduced benefits: it recently stopped paying for prenatal care for high-risk women and for nonemergency hemodialysis. Although immigrants make up a minority of the uninsured, Mercado said media reports regularly blame illegal immigrants for the worsening problems of the state's health care system. Anger over high medical costs and reduced access to care no doubt contributes to anti-immigrant sentiment; the remedy, however, is not immigrant bashing, but health care reform.
“As an American citizen, I understand that you want to make sure the resources are there for the right people,” Mercado said. “Yet how can you deny someone health access? If we don't treat and prevent illness . . . our whole community is going to suffer.”
Source Information
Dr. Okie is a contributing editor of the Journal.
- References
References
1
Mohanty SA ,Woolhandler S ,Himmelstein DU ,Pati S ,Carrasquillo O ,Bor DH . Health care expenditures of immigrants in the United States: a nationally representative analysis. Am J Public Health 2005;95:1431-1438
CrossRef | Web of Science | Medline2
Goldman DP ,Smith JP ,Sood N . Immigrants and the cost of medical care. Health Aff (Millwood) 2006;25:1700-1711
CrossRef | Web of Science | Medline3
DuBard CA ,Massing MW . Trends in emergency Medicaid expenditures for recent and undocumented immigrants. JAMA 2007;297:1085-1092[Erratum, JAMA 2007;297:1774.]
CrossRef | Web of Science | Medline4
Brown ER, Pourat N, Wallace SP. Undocumented residents make up small share of California's uninsured population. Los Angeles: UCLA Center for Health Policy Research, March 2007.
5
Pear R. Lacking papers, citizens are cut from Medicaid. New York Times. March 12, 2007:A1.
- Citing Articles (27)
Citing Articles
1
Donald W. Light. (2012) Categorical inequality, institutional ambivalence, and permanently failing institutions: the case of immigrants and barriers to health care in America. Ethnic and Racial Studies 35:1, 23-39
CrossRef2
Choong-Hyung Lee, Jae-Moon Yun, Jong-Soo Han, Sang-Min Park, Young-Su Park, Seung-Kwon Hong. (2012) The Prevalence of Chronic Diseases among Migrants in Korea According to Their Length of Stay and Residential Status. Korean Journal of Family Medicine 33:1, 34
CrossRef3
Carolyn Sargent, Stéphanie Larchanché. (2011) Transnational Migration and Global Health: The Production and Management of Risk, Illness, and Access to Care *. Annual Review of Anthropology 40:1, 345-361
CrossRef4
Sarah S. Willen, Jessica Mulligan, Heide Castañeda. (2011) Take a Stand Commentary: How Can Medical Anthropologists Contribute to Contemporary Conversations on “Illegal” Im/migration and Health?. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 25:3, 331-356
CrossRef5
C. del Rio. (2011) Latinos and HIV Care in the Southeastern United States: New Challenges Complicating Longstanding Problems. Clinical Infectious Diseases 53:5, 488-489
CrossRef6
Jie Chen, Arturo Vargas-Bustamante. (2011) Estimating the Effects of Immigration Status on Mental Health Care Utilizations in the United States. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health 13:4, 671-680
CrossRef7
Mark A. Hall. (2011) The Mission of Safety Net Organizations Following National Insurance Reform. Journal of General Internal Medicine 26:7, 802-805
CrossRef8
Josphine Chaumba. (2011) Health Status, Use of Health Care Resources, and Treatment Strategies of Ethiopian and Nigerian Immigrants in the United States. Social Work in Health Care 50:6, 466-481
CrossRef9
Maria Isabel Rodriguez, Lisa Angus, Emily Elman, Philip D. Darney, Aaron B. Caughey. (2011) Financial effect of instituting Deficit Reduction Act documentation requirements in family planning clinics in Oregon. Contraception 83:6, 537-541
CrossRef10
Anahí Viladrich. (2011) Beyond welfare reform: Reframing undocumented immigrants’ entitlement to health care in the United States, a critical review. Social Science & Medicine
CrossRef11
Leo R. Chavez. (2011) Undocumented immigrants and their use of medical services in Orange County, California. Social Science & Medicine
CrossRef12
Katie L. Crosslin, Ray Tsai, Claudia V. Romo, Adela Tsai. (2011) Acculturation in Hispanics and childhood poisoning: Are medicines and household cleaners stored properly?. Accident Analysis & Prevention 43:3, 1010-1014
CrossRef13
Hall, Mark A., . (2011) Rethinking Safety-Net Access for the Uninsured. New England Journal of Medicine 364:1, 7-9
Full Text14
Maria A. Schoevers, Maria E. T. C. van den Muijsenbergh, Antoine L. M. Lagro-Janssen. (2010) Illegal female immigrants in The Netherlands have unmet needs in sexual and reproductive health. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics & Gynecology 31:4, 256-264
CrossRef15
Marianne A. Schoevers, Maartje J. Loeffen, Maria E. Muijsenbergh, Antoine L. M. Lagro-Janssen. (2010) Health care utilisation and problems in accessing health care of female undocumented immigrants in the Netherlands. International Journal of Public Health 55:5, 421-428
CrossRef16
Maria Isabel Rodriguez, Aaron B. Caughey, Alison Edelman, Philip D. Darney, Diana Greene Foster. (2010) Cost–benefit analysis of state- and hospital-funded postpartum intrauterine contraception at a university hospital for recent immigrants to the United States. Contraception 81:4, 304-308
CrossRef17
Maria Isabel Rodriguez, Jeffrey T. Jensen, Philip D. Darney, Sarah E. Little, Aaron B. Caughey. (2010) The Financial Effects of Expanding Postpartum Contraception for New Immigrants. Obstetrics & Gynecology 115:3, 552-558
CrossRef18
Eleanor D. Kinney. (2009) Realization of the International Human Right to Health in an Economically Integrated North America. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 37:4, 807-818
CrossRef19
Mardge H Cohen. (2009) Commentary: Undocumented women: Pushed from poverty and conflict, pulled into unjust disparity. Journal of Public Health Policy 30:4, 423-426
CrossRef20
M A Schoevers, M E T C van den Muijsenbergh, A L M Lagro-Janssen. (2009) Self-rated health and health problems of undocumented immigrant women in the Netherlands: A descriptive study. Journal of Public Health Policy 30:4, 409-422
CrossRef21
Krista J. Hachey, Rebecca H. Allen, Melissa Nothnagle, Lori A. Boardman. (2009) Requiring Human Papillomavirus Vaccine for Immigrant Women. Obstetrics & Gynecology 114:5, 1135-1139
CrossRef22
Herbert Y. Reynolds. (2009) Free Medical Clinics: Helping Indigent Patients and Dealing With Emerging Health Care Needs. Academic Medicine 84:10, 1434-1439
CrossRef23
Leighton Ku. (2009) Health Insurance Coverage and Medical Expenditures of Immigrants and Native-Born Citizens in the United States. American Journal of Public Health 99:7, 1322-1328
CrossRef24
Paul K. Drain, King K. Holmes, Kelley M. Skeff, Thomas L. Hall, Pierce Gardner. (2009) Global Health Training and International Clinical Rotations During Residency: Current Status, Needs, and Opportunities. Academic Medicine 84:3, 320-325
CrossRef25
John G. Hunter. (2009) Reducing U.S. Health Care Spending: Is It Realistic or Even Desirable?. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 123:1, 403-408
CrossRef26
Daniel G. Cobos, Jonathan Winston Jones. (2008) Promoting Passage Through Care: How to Best Serve Undocumented Immigrants With HIV. Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS care 19:4, 320-324
CrossRef27
Luis López Lázaro. (2008) Inmigración, estado de salud y uso de servicios de atención primaria. Atención Primaria 40:5, 232-233
CrossRef
